Is It Time To Get Rid of Your Beanie Babies? Here’s What They Could Be Worth Today

X (Twitter) Facebook Pinterest LinkedIn Flip it

Any child of the 90s will get a pang of nostalgia when they hear the name Beanie Babies. You might even still have them tucked away somewhere or set up on a shelf, waiting for the day when they’ll be worth selling. Many collectors are wondering the same thing: is that day today? And if so, what could I get for them? Let’s take a look at the world of Beanie Babies and see if it’s time to cash in on your collection.

Evaluating Your Collection

Let’s start with determining the condition of your Beanie Baby collection. Here are some tips to help you understand their potential worth.

Condition Is Everything

Mint condition items with tags still attached will virtually always be worth more than those with clear wear and tear or without their tags. Inspect each one carefully and note of any imperfections or damage.

Check for Rare Editions

Some Beanie Babies are more valuable than others because of their rarity. The Princess Diana bear is a good example, often fetching extremely high prices, especially if they’re in good enough condition.

Try Price Guides

Comb through online resources and price guides specific to Beanie Babies. You can also check eBay to see what the current market value for any given toy is, looking through completed sales to see what others spent on similar items.

So What Is a Beanie Baby Worth Today?

The answer to this question will depend on three things: rarity, condition, and demand. Many common Beanie Babies are worth only a few dollars, but rarer ones can sell for impressive amounts. Here’s a quick breakdown of what you might expect to sell yours for:

Common Beanie Babies typically range from $5 to $20. The majority of Beanie Babies will fall into this category.
Rare Beanie Babies are usually limited-edition and can go for as little as $20 all the way up to several hundreds. This is the “mid-tier,” and often the prices here rely more heavily on things like condition and demand.
Exceedingly rare finds, like the Princess Diana bear we mentioned earlier, are often sold for thousands of dollars, especially if they’re in good condition with their original tags.

Is It Time To Hold or Sell?

Now it’s time for the real question: do you hold on to your collection or sell it if the price is right? If your Beanie Babies hold sentimental value, this is a hard question to answer. In most instances, you’ll probably want to keep these, regardless of their monetary worth, rather than part with something you love.

If you bought them or are hanging onto them solely as investments, then you may want to get more familiar with market trends before you sell. Many argue that the Beanie Baby market in specific has stabilized, but it’s still the mark of a savvy seller to collect as much data as possible before making money moves.