Garlic: The Most Popular Plant in the Fall, and for Good Reason

Fall is synonymous with pumpkins, but Americans don’t want to grow pumpkins this fall!

Americans really want to grow garlic, a new study shows. Garlic is America’s most popular fall crop, with 12 states searching for how to grow it more than any other fall crop.

Gardening experts at All About Gardening analyzed Google Trends data to establish the fall crop with the highest search volume for the search term ‘How To Grow’ in each American state in the past five years.

This research revealed the fall crop each American state wants to learn how to grow, and garlic was the most popular.


The analysis revealed that garlic had the highest number of states searching for it the most out of any fall crop, with twelve American states, including Delaware, Wyoming, New York, and Hawaii.

Organic vegetable specialist Logan Haily commented on the best environment to grow garlic: “Garlic is a true lover of cold weather. Most varieties actually need a prolonged period of chilly temps (called vernalization) to develop hefty, easy-to-cut bulbs. Northern growers should opt for hardneck varieties that can chill under the frost and snow of winter. Southern growers should opt for softneck varieties that don’t need the cold treatment of vernalization. Alternatively, you can pre-chill your seed garlic in the refrigerator.”



Broccoli is the second most popular fall crop, with eight states searching for how to grow them more than any other vegetable, including Michigan, California, Georgia, and West Virginia.

Logan says that if you want to grow broccoli, “The seeds require 85 to 100 days to mature into full heads. You can extend the harvest after cutting the initial head by harvesting side shoots throughout late autumn.”



A total of seven states searched for how to grow onions the most out of any fall crop – the third highest number of states in the research. States with residents searching for how to grow onions the most include Oklahoma, Indiana, Texas, and Alabama.

Logan comments on how to grow onions and scallions properly, “Whether you prefer green onions or full-sized bulbs, these pungent alliums readily tolerate the cold. Onions are fairly hardy and can withstand temperatures down to about 20°F. You can use row cover or deep mulches to encourage them to go dormant over the winter and re-sprout in the spring.”


Portrait of attractive caucasian smiling woman eating salad, focus on hand and fork. soft, backlight.
Image Credit: SunCity/Shutterstock.

Lettuce was the most searched-for fall crop in six states – Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Mississippi, New Jersey, and Virginia, making it the fourth most popular fall crop.

To best grow lettuce, Logan advises that “Lettuce seeds can germinate in soils as cold as 40°F and do not do well in hot soil temps above 75°F. Therefore, in most climates, September and October are the ideal times to start getting fall lettuce off to a great start. Then, you can “cut and come again” if you leave the center growing tip intact.”


Carrots were the fall crop with the most searches for how to grow them in Tennessee, Pennsylvania, Nevada, Washington, and North Dakota.

To achieve flavorful carrots, Logan advises: “Most people don’t realize that carrots get their characteristic sweetness from cold weather… If you want to enjoy the most deliciously candy-like carrots, plant them in the fall and harvest them throughout the winter! Carrots prefer to be out of the heat and thrive in the cold. As one of the most versatile garden veggies, you can grow carrots in zones 2 through 11. When planted in October through November, they can establish during the cooler weather when there is typically plenty of rain to keep them evenly moist.”

Radishes, Cauliflower, Brussel Sprouts, and Collard Greens

Four fall crops came joint sixth, with two states interested in growing these crops – radishes, cauliflower, Brussel sprouts, and collard greens – more than any other.

The states that wanted to learn how to grow radishes more than any other fall crop were Idaho and Kansas.

A quick tip Logan shares for anyone wanting to learn how to radishes: “Radishes aren’t particularly frost-hardy, but they grow fast, making them perfect for sneaking into the empty spaces of your fall garden. These red roots also come in purple, white, pink, yellow, and black. Northern growers may prefer to harvest autumn radishes before hard frosts, remove the greens, and store them in the refrigerator for winter use. Southern growers can hold them in the garden and pull as needed (just don’t let them get too oversized!).”

The states of Arizona and Connecticut searched for how to grow cauliflower more than any other fall crop.

Logan advises the following temperatures for anyone looking to grow their cauliflower: “Cauliflower prefers to grow at a mild 50 to 60°F and complete 60-70% of its vegetative growth before the cold sets in. Then, you can use a cold frame to protect cauliflower that you plant later.”

Missouri and Ohio Brussel sprouts were also the most searched fall crop to learn how to grow in Missouri and Ohio.

The secret to perfectly grown sprouts, Logan reveals, is to space them out: “You can plant brussels sprouts in the first cool days of fall in an area with plenty of space and direct sunlight. Then, prepare seedlings indoors in late summer or direct seed into the garden about four months before the expected first frost. Each plant prefers at least 18-24” of space and plenty of fertilizer to fuel their growth.”

The states of Massachusetts and Minnesota searched for how to grow collard greens more than any other fall crop.

Logan advises the following for anyone looking to grow collard greens: “They have the same amount of nutrition as their “superfood” kale cousins, and they handle the cold like champs. You should start seedlings in June or July for fall harvests. Transplants can be set out from August to October in northern zones and reliably overwintered in mild regions.”

Different Fall Crops

Four different fall crops were the most popular crop in just one state each, with those crops being spinach, peas, beetroot, and cabbage.

Spinach was the most searched-for fall crop in only one state – Wisconsin.

Logan says spinach can actually be sweeter in the Autumn: “Autumn spinach has more sweetness and bolt-resistance than spring and summer greens. Plus, it can be harvested just 30 days from the time of seeding!”

Meanwhile, peas were also the top searched fall crop to learn how to grow in only one state, with that state being Arkansas.

To ensure you get the best type of peas, Logan suggests planning ahead: “Whether you prefer sugar snap, snow peas, or shelling peas, these legumes love chilly weather. Once they’re rooted in place, they can handle temperatures slightly below freezing. However, they prefer the 45 to 65°F range for optimal growth. You should plant peas 8-10 weeks before your first frost so they have time to flower and start “podding” up. The time frame is typically between August and October. Light frosts and snows won’t damage the peas, but heavy freezes will.”

Beetroot was the most searched-for fall crop in the state of Utah.

Logan warns not to let beets freeze: “You can seed beets (or even transplant them) throughout the fall until about ten weeks before your first heavy freeze. If the ground freezes too hard, you may risk the roots splitting or rotting. However, light frosts are just fine and even yield sweeter roots.”

The last fall crop on the list is cabbage. Cabbage is the most popular fall crop in South Carolina.

Logan reveals that September is the ideal time to start growing cabbage: “While some fall cabbages need to be established in late summer, you can still get away with transplanting cabbage seedlings as late as September in most growing zones. This will give them ample time to develop robust leaves and root systems that will fuel the growth of the central head as the trees change color around them.”

Read More:

This post was produced by A Dime Saved.

Hi! I am a millennial mom with a passion for personal finance. I have always been “into” personal finance but got inspired to start my blog after a period of extended unemployment. That experience really changed the way I viewed my relationship with money and the importance of accessible personal finance education.